Note: I wrote the following and thought I'd share it for critical feedback and improvement suggestions. Please leave those in the Comments area.
Thanks, Miguel
7 Questions (and Tips!) for Developing a BYOT Campus Strategy
by Miguel Guhlin
“Have you stopped and taken a breath about what BYOT means for YOU, your teachers, students, and parents?” That’s a question that is screaming its way into the rarified atmosphere of public schools, like a cataclysmic meteor that some may avoid thinking about until it smashes their reality. If that seems unnecessarily confrontational, it's an apt analogy for students' changing expectations for what school should be like. With that reality-smashing scenario in mind, many schools are coming to terms, one way or another, with bring your own technology (BYOT).
Bring your own technology (BYOT) intrigues many, frightens others. As a result of that fear and concern, it’s critical that campus leadership teams craft a strategy to implement BYOT.
This article offers two approaches you can use as part of a “strategy session” for campus leaders: 1) BYOT Scenario - In this problem-based learning scenario, explore BYOT issues from your particular role and try to develop a solution. This is best used for open discussion in a face to face meeting session.
2) 7 Question Checklist - Use this checklist to self-reflect as individuals or as a group as to whether you have addressed some key ideas. Links are provided to help you access appropriate resources.
Before exploring these two approaches, consider the inevitability of BYOT in schools.
THE INEVITABILITY OF BYOT
“BYOT- it happens no matter what, it's only called BYOT," shares Josh Davis, "when your curriculum takes advantage of it."
Some statistics to keep in mind:
- Young adults tend to have higher-than-average levels of smartphone ownership regardless of income or educational attainment. (Source: http://bit.ly/VgOU9U)
- More Hispanic (49 percent) and African-American (42 percent) middle school students are using their smartphones for homework than Caucasian students (36 percent). (Source: http://goo.gl/eGUQ2)
- Smartphone use for homework also crosses income levels, with 29 percent of the students from the lowest-income households reporting smartphone usage to do their homework assignments.(Source: http://goo.gl/eGUQ2)
- More than one in three middle school students are using mobile devices to complete homework, and more of those who use these devices for learning in the classroom express a strong interest in science, technology and math than those who do not, according to a new national survey. (Source: http://goo.gl/eGUQ2)
- Nationwide, 55% of middle and high school students, as well as 25% of elementary students, own a mobile device (e.g. cell phone).
- Teens in the lowest income category are most likely to use their phones, instead of computers to go online.
PROBLEM-SOLVING STRATEGIES“Effective leadership without consistent, clear communication,” shares one District Technology Director, “does not exist” The scenario below--intended to tease out differing perspectives on BYOT--will help you reflect on the issues that arise when implementing BYOT:
In
a few weeks, students like John and Maria at a 5A high school will be
bringing their own technology to school. While some teachers like
Jennifer are excited about the possibilities--mainly, those that have
taken the time to learn how to use the Read/Write Web to collaborate,
create, connect in alignment with academic goals--others like Rick are
afraid things will not work as well. He’s comfortable with students
working on paper and pencil/pen, not using their own devices and what
they might do on them when he isn’t looking.
James,
the campus principal recognizes the need for a campus strategy towards
BYOT. He’s worried that teachers will fail to take advantage of BYOT
in their lessons and BYOT use will become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
“Failure,” he points out with a smile, “just isn’t an option in our
small community.” This is a fact the District Technology Department and
District Leadership are well aware of as well. The Classroom Learning Activity Rubric is one instrument that’s been offered to help teachers employ strategies that take advantage of technology in the classroom.
Parents like Ms. Jones (involved in the PTA) are wondering, How
will the school communicate with me about this and will there be a
consistent message from campus leaders? Will that message match what
teachers are saying and doing in the classroom when students misbehave?
So much is at stake, jobs are the on the line, high stakes
accountability is in play. At a time when technology is everywhere,
teaching, learning, and leading with technology has real consequences.
As you reflect on this scenario, ask yourself some questions, such as the ones below:
- What hunches (intuitive guesses) do you have about this scenario?
- What do we know for certain about the problem?
- What questions can we ask that will get us the information we need to help the protagonist solve the problem?
- Who are the stakeholders in this scenario and what solutions do we need to develop for their particular situation?
Pick a stakeholder role--teacher, campus leader, technology department, student, parent--that you have some affinity with, then try to develop a solution. Consider using a KWHL chart like the one below to get you started.
Here's an example to get you started; it's not intended to be all-inclusive of the conversations embedded in the role of Campus Leader.
Stakeholder Role: Campus Leader
| What do I Know? | What I Want to Know? | How will I find Information? | What have I learned? |
| What is expected of me as a campus leader? How can I better support classroom teachers and encourage them to use BYOT? How can BYOT enhance instruction rather than become a self-fulfilling prophecy? How do I hold teachers accountable for what they are doing or not doing? | The District’s BYOT Support site has resources online at http://bit.ly/ecbyot Check the webinar schedule on the BYOT Support Site for more training at http://bit.ly/ecbyotteacher |
7 Questions and Tips for Developing a BYOT Campus Strategy
Another approach, once you’ve explored BYOT from various stakeholder roles, is to review the checklist on the next page and ask, How am I going to get there from here? Make this as specific as you can for YOUR role on campus.
7 Question BYOT Checklist
| Item | Question to Ponder | Taking Action |
1.
| Have you defined and aligned the goals for the BYOT program to the Campus Improvement Plan and District Mission? | Tip: Connect BYOT use to differentiated instruction, the District’s mission, and specific instructional strategies in your CIP. |
2.
| Have
you outlined expectations for teachers, students about using Edmodo.com
and GoogleApps to create online, virtual classrooms? | Tip: Encourage teachers to spend some classroom time answering questions from students on how they will use technologies in class. |
3.
| Have
you decided what to do when students and/or staff bring too many
devices that slow down the network (1 BYOT device per person is
recommended)? | Tip: Let students know they can only connect 1 wireless device to the network. |
4.
| How will teachers be supported on campus--not just District Professional Development--to transform classroom learning activities from being paper-focused to electronic to eliminate the need for printing (for example, students can’t print from BYOT devices)? | Tip: Use the Classroom Learning Activity Rubric at http://bit.ly/ecbyotteacher |
5.
| How will you share BYOT program goals, define expectations, show students what they can do with the device, help students connect to the wireless network, and address concerns from stakeholders? | Tip: Encourage teachers to attend online webinars they can participate in from their classroom or home; have frequent parent communications; share with staff what is appropriate to say about BYOT. Instead of, “It’s not working,” encourage them to say, “We’re all working together to learn how to best take advantage of BYOT in the classroom.” |
6.
| How will campus leaders and teachers respond to questions of equity (e.g. I can’t afford to buy my child a device)? | Tip: Share that the campus has devices available for students who can’t or don’t want to bring their own to school. The more BYOT is practiced, the more school devices are available for those with the greatest need. |
7.
| How should I answer questions from staff/students/parents about which devices to use? | Tip: Refer to the BYOT Mobile Device Chart online at http://bit.ly/ecbyot |
Conclusion
As you have seen, the focus of these crucial conversations involves flushing out tough questions in advance, clearly laying out answers to anticipated questions so that all stakeholders know what's up, and constantly asking, What questions am I not asking that will enhance instruction now that we have these devices available?
